Avoid the $5,000 Mistake: Why Tenant Renewals Matter More Than Management Fees
Avoid the $5,000 Mistake: Why Tenant Renewals Matter More Than Management Fees
If you own a rental property in Northeast Florida, you've probably compared property managers based on monthly fees. That’s fair—cost matters. But here’s something most people don’t realize:
Saving $50–$75 a month with a discount management company might cost you $5,000 (or more) in the long run.
At Nest Finders, we track a key metric that many owners overlook: our tenant renewal rate. Right now, 70.3% of our residents renew their lease, and that number says a lot—not just about our team, but about how we protect your bottom line.
Why You Should Care About Renewals
Every time a great tenant renews their lease, here’s what you don’t have to deal with:
- Cleaning and repairs
- Weeks (or months) of vacancy
- Marketing costs and leasing fees
- Stress, uncertainty, and paperwork
In today’s rental market, where turnover is more common and rental competition is fierce, keeping the right tenant in place is gold. That’s why our 70.3% renewal rate matters—it’s not just a stat, it’s money in your pocket.
How We Get Tenants to Stay
Tenants don’t renew by accident. They renew because they feel taken care of—and that starts with how we manage your property day in and day out.
Fast maintenance troubleshooting
We solve issues quickly (and often without sending out vendors for simple fixes). That saves you money and earns tenant loyalty.
Quick, quality repairs
Nothing frustrates residents faster than waiting weeks to get something fixed. We don’t let that happen.
Real communication
Our team treats tenants like people, not problems. That respect goes a long way.
Smart renewal pricing
We don’t push tenants away with aggressive increases. We study the market and advise you on a rent that makes sense and keeps the right people in place.
The Real Cost of a “Budget” Manager
Sure, a company offering $50–$75 less per month may seem like a deal. But let’s take a look at what one tenant turnover could cost you in today’s market, keep in mind current days on market on 50, we average 30:
| Expense | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|
| Vacancy (50 days @ $1,800/month) Current market average | ~$3,000 |
| Cleaning, repairs, and prep work | $400–$1,200 |
| Leasing fee (75% of one month’s rent) | $1,350 |
| Total Turnover Cost (Market Avg) | $4,750–$5,550+ |
The Hidden Costs of Poor Management
A low fee might come at a high price. Here’s what we’ve seen from owners who come to us after working with discount managers:
- Slow maintenance response = tenant frustration
- Poor communication = negative reviews and legal risk
- Weak leasing = longer vacancies and lower-quality renters
- No preventative care = big repair bills down the road
- Lack of oversight = more hands-on stress for you
The Nest Finders Difference
We don’t race to the bottom with pricing—we focus on long-term performance. And our numbers speak for themselves:
- 70.3% renewal rate
- Happier tenants
- Less vacancy
- Predictable income
- Protected investments
We’re here to help you build consistent cash flow and long-term wealth—not just manage your property.
Ready to Protect Your Rental Income?
If you're with Nest Finders already, thank you for letting us take care of your home and your tenants.
If you're still exploring your options, let’s talk. We’ll walk you through how we operate, show you the numbers, and help you make the best decision for your rental and your peace of mind.
👉 Schedule
